Thursday, May 28, 2009

Pro-life Leader of The Catholic League Roots for Sotomayor ... Tells GOP Not to Fight "This One"

Writing in The Washington Times, our friend Victor Morton reports on Bill Donohue's surprising announcement of support for the Sotomayor nomination:
A prominent pro-life Catholic says he will be quietly rooting for Judge Sonia Sotomayor to be confirmed to the Supreme Court and said she may even be an improvement over retiring Justice David H. Souter - as both sides of the abortion issue try to discern her position.

William Donohue, president of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights, said Judge Sotomayor's record has more bright spots than conservative Catholics can reasonably expect to get from an appointee of President Obama.

"If the Republicans are smart, they would not fight this one," he told The Washington Times in an interview Thursday.

"I wish I knew more about her. But from what we know, it looks like she'll be at least a wash with Souter, and maybe we'll even see improvement."

The White House said that Mr. Obama did not specifically ask her about her views on the issue but that the president is confident she agrees with him on the fundamental constitutional issues.

But pro-choice groups are uncertain about Judge Sotomayor, and this week they called on senators to ask her directly how she would rule on Roe v. Wade, the 1973 Supreme Court decision that established a constitutional right to an abortion.

"We encourage the Senate Judiciary Committee to engage Judge Sotomayor and any future nominees to the Court on their commitment to the principles of Roe v. Wade," said Nancy Northup, president of the Center for Reproductive Rights. "Anything less threatens not only a woman's constitutional rights, but her life and health."
Victor also gets a quote from another friend of this blog, Steve "Feddie" Dillard:
Mr. Donohue was not alone among conservative Catholics in calling for pro-lifers to hold their fire.

"My concern is that the people in Obama's on-deck circle are much worse," said Steve Dillard, an adviser to the 2008 presidential campaign of Mike Huckabee and founder of the site Catholics Against Rudy. He called Judge Sotomayor "the best of the worst."

"Do you really want to win this battle only to get Diane Wood?" said Mr. Dillard, a lawyer and former clerk at the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, where Judge Wood, whom he called a brilliant radical, sits.
Exactly right. Donohue concurs:
Mr. Donohue also suggested that opposing Judge Sotomayor's confirmation would not be wise in the short term, in terms of who the alternative nominee might be.

"I am looking at this pool of likely competitors, and, far and away, Sotomayor is the best candidate," he said, adding that making too big a political fight over the Sotomayor pick "might look like we have an agenda that will not look good to many in the Latino community."
My Comments:
I have a dream:
I have a dream that one day I meet Feddie on a train platform. Associate Justice Sotomayor has just joined the Supreme Court majority in overturning Roe v. Wade in the landmark decision Planned Parenthood v. South Dakota, and I know how thrilled Feddie must be because I am in a similar state of euphoria. We start running through the crowd toward each other, and when we meet, we embrace, laughing and crying. An ecstatic Feddie weeps tears of joy, telling me over and over: “We were right about telling conservatives to hold their fire on Sotomayor! ... We were right!” The two of us are so jubilant, so giddy — practically dancing — that onlookers think we are crazy; but we just keep laughing and yelling and hugging each other because sometimes, there are happy endings.
Do I think such a scenario is likely? No. For one thing, the likelihood of Feddie and me appearing on the same train platform is somewhere between slim and none. For another thing, I am fairly sure that Sotomayor is a conventional liberal who would vote to uphold Roe should the opportunity ever present itself.

Still, a guy can dream (and pray) can't he?

Previous Pro Ecclesia posts on this subject:
NY Times: "On Sotomayor, Some Abortion Rights Backers Show Unease"

Round-Up of Reactions to Sotomayor Pick [UPDATED]

Supreme Court-Related Quote of the Day ... [UPDATED]

Sotomayor Blurs Lines in Abortion War [UPDATED]

My Advice for Conservatives Re: Judge Sotomayor [UPDATED]

Conservatives, Liberals, and Supreme Court Picks

Labels: , , , , , ,


At 5/28/2009 10:54 PM, Blogger Tito Edwards said...

I'll be popping a bottle of champagne (and scotch) in celebration!

Yes, we are allowed to dream!

At 5/28/2009 10:58 PM, Blogger James H said...

LOL great play on the Biden thing

At 5/28/2009 11:26 PM, Blogger Paul, just this guy, you know? said...

I have a dream that one day I meet Feddie...

Laugh out loud funny. But it only ever happens the other way.

At 5/29/2009 2:28 AM, Anonymous Michele said...

I am glad that I am not alone in my thoughts that although she probably is a liberal on abortion, she is as good as it gets from Obama.

My advice is don't fight also

At 5/30/2009 12:18 PM, Anonymous Boethius said...


Perhaps your chance of meeting Feddie under such circumstances is not so slim. After all, after meeting in the blogosphere, we once stood together on a roller coaster platform in Sandusky.

I disagree with you about Sotomayor, however. The point is not to try to defeat her nomination. You're right we likely would get someone worse. Not to mention, there's not really a chance at defeating her with 59 Democrats in the Senate. The point is to expose President Obama's radical view of the American judiciary by asking her tough (but civil) questions at the confirmation hearings. We explain how the views of Sotomayor contrast with the views of Roberts and Alito, and we vote no on her confirmation, just as President Obama voted no on Roberts and Alito.

Then, after she's confirmed, when she starts making liberal decisions, Republican Senators can say, see I told you so: She's an activist liberal imposing policy from the bench, just as we said she would.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

hit counter for blogger