Friday, January 11, 2008

GetReligion on Archbishop Chaput on GetReligion

Another interesting post by Terry Mattingly at GetReligion, this one covering Denver Archbishop Charles J. Chaput's recent column in The Denver Catholic Register in which he praised ... GetReligion:
... the archbishop’s interest in journalism is frequently evident in in his newspaper columns and speeches. He is considered a pro-Rome conservative, but rare are the traditionalists who pay this much attention to trends in media and modern life. Many Catholic liberals detest him (think abortion politics), but he also makes a few conservatives nervous from time to time (think death penalty and economic issues). Catholic theology tends to shred labels.

All of this is to note that, in a new column in the Denver Catholic Register, the archbishop has praised GetReligion — for reasons that both needle and praise mainstream journalists. Here is a sample: is one of my favorite Web sites, not because it’s Catholic or pious — it’s neither — but because it asks the right questions. . . . The results aren’t comforting. The evidence gathered by shows again and again that the press doesn’t “get” religion as a story. Denver is unusual in having two major newspapers, both with capable religion coverage. But overall, major news organizations tend to cover religion poorly, predictably and too often with a negative undercurrent.

As we enter yet another election year, Catholics should remember that what we read in the newspapers, hear on the radio and see on television is often useful, but it’s always a selective taste of reality. Deciding about a candidate based on the latest headlines, or about an issue based on the latest reported poll, is a recipe for trouble.
Journalists, of course, would want to debate with the archbishop about that phrase “predictably and too often” being used to describe negative coverage of religion news. That’s a debate he would welcome and it would be a lively one.

When it comes to GetReligion, Chaput specifically wanted to praise Mark Stricherz for challenging mainstream journalists to dig into religious issues and debates among Democrats as well as Republicans. Click here and then here for the posts in question. As the archbishop notes, “obviously, plenty of very good people, including many religious believers, inhabit both political parties.” Why not cover both stories?
Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and John Edwards have all spoken quite publicly about their religious faith in recent months. Yet as Stricherz notes, the recent Iowa caucus poll supported by all four major TV networks, CNN and AP was framed in a way that presumed religion is a major factor for Republicans and not for Democrats. Maybe that’s true; maybe it’s not — but we won’t ever know from the poll results, because the right questions weren’t asked.

Labels: ,


At 1/11/2008 6:02 PM, Blogger James H said...

Great article. I enjoy him a lot. THe article is right. He does know and is more importantly aware how important it is to use and get the message out there in the MSM

At 1/12/2008 10:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fred Thompson Wanted to Get Rid of GOP Platform in 1996

Tennesseans for Choice questionnaire

Thompson in Favor of First Trimester Abortions in 1994

Thompson rated with a “C” by Americans for Better Immigration

Thompson supports McCain-Feingold bill

Thompson authored McCain-Feingold-Thompson!

Thompson did not always support Reagan

Thompson's REAL record on abortion

Deacon Keith Fournier slams Thompson for attacking Huckabee


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

hit counter for blogger