Friday, July 28, 2006

Op/Ed: Clergy Too Quiet About Bush, War

The following Op/Ed by some television producer/art instructor appearing in the Atlanta Urinal Constipation is in need of a good "fisking". Unfortunately, I don't have time to do it today. Maybe I'll come back to it. In the meantime, if any commenters want a take a shot at it, be my guest.
Clergy too quiet about Bush, war

By KENNETH C. DANIEL
Published on: 07/27/06


A few years ago, there was a popular bumper sticker and bracelet. It was the essence of simplicity; four letters, followed by a question mark — WWJD? What Would Jesus Do? Most of the stickers have either faded into oblivion or have been replaced by other causes, such as Support Our Troops or God Bless America.

As the WWJD bumper stickers disappeared, did the message vanish as well? The idea began to haunt me. The more I mulled it over, the darker and more foreboding the tempest swirled, until a single question emerged from this maelstrom of thoughts and emotions: Where is the voice of our spiritual leaders? Where are the sentinels of our souls, raising their voices, asking the tough questions, protesting injustice, condemning corruption?

So, I ask you, clergy, where is your voice?

• WWJD about a war initiated on deception in which, every day, men and women — American, Iraqi, Afghani and others — are dying?

• WWJD about so many of our leaders who loudly proclaim their Christian faith and devotion to God to gain our vote, then, once elected, lie and cheat and deceive?

• WWJD about a government that places more importance on corporate profit than on the environment or the welfare of its citizens?

• WWJD about a government that closes its eyes to so many countries where every day thousands of men, women and children die from diseases that can be easily prevented with affordable, accessible medicines? Or a government that protects the obscene profiteering of its medical and pharmaceutical corporations while hundreds of thousands of its own citizens are unable to afford medical insurance and treatment and die needlessly?

• WWJD with those of us who cry "traitor" and "un-American" at anyone who even so slightly questions our motives in the Middle East, even a mother whose son died there?

Where is the logic in fighting a war on terrorism with every terrifying weapon available to us, just short of nuclear bombs? I'm fairly certain Jesus had a clear position on this.

And we wonder why so many people all over the world hate us. We continually claim that it is because they are envious of our prosperity, when the real reason is our insistence that everyone must submit to our rules. We wave the flag, puff out our chests and proclaim, "God is on our side." And, of course, our God is male, white and conservative Christian.

I ask you, when did the God of compassion, inclusion, tolerance and forgiveness become the God of retribution, condemnation and punishment? Is your silence prompted by a fear that your congregation might be offended and reduce their offerings? Or that the government will reassess your tax status? Or perhaps you have convinced yourself that politics and religion should be kept separate?

So, I ask again, where is your voice? How much more can you tolerate before you speak out?

Perhaps the question now should not be, WWJD? Perhaps the more appropriate question should be, WWYD?

What will you do?


Kenneth C. Daniel is a television producer and instructor at the Art Institute of Atlanta.

4 Comments:

At 7/28/2006 10:45 PM, Blogger Sir Galen of Bristol said...

I say, when liberals are willing to listen to clergy about abortion, embryonic stem cell research, and gay "marriage", then I'll believe that they're interested in morality, and not just hoping for another voice that agrees with them on a single point.

 
At 7/29/2006 7:07 AM, Blogger Brother James said...

Fisking done here:

http://shakingoffsleep.blogspot.com/2006/07/clerical-silence-and-moral-babbling.html

 
At 7/29/2006 6:54 PM, Blogger Fr Martin Fox said...

In the lead up to the war, I had some things to say about whether we ought to go to war; but I felt a need to be circumspect then, because the teaching on just war calls for the decision to be made by "lawful authority" -- so one has to allow some deference.

After the war started, it became a different question. The primary moral obligation, as I see it, is for the U.S. to keep their word to the Iraqis -- or, if you prefer, to clean up our own mess. I have not chosen to make this point from the pulpit -- is that the kind of silence the authors were talking about?

 
At 7/30/2006 10:57 AM, Blogger Dymphna said...

At my parish we have two regular visiting priests who usually preach against the war and against Israel. It's a real bee in their bonnets. Never a word about Christ only attacks on Israel and comments about the poor oppressed Muslims.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

hit counter for blogger